Beat IPO Hype
Nolan O'Connor
| 18-11-2025

· News team
Hey Lykkers! Ever seen a company's stock price double on its first trading day and felt that FOMO kicking in? That exhilarating, often irrational, excitement around new stocks is what we call IPO Mania.
It's like the stock market's version of a blockbuster movie premiere - all flashbulbs and red carpets. But behind the glamour, how do you tell if you're looking at the next Amazon or the next WeWork?
Let's cut through the noise together. I'll show you how to separate the genuine innovators from the hype machines, so you can make informed decisions instead of getting caught in the frenzy.
The Siren Song of the IPO
An Initial Public Offering (IPO) represents a company's debut on the public markets. It's that moment when a private company decides to sell shares to the public. The excitement is understandable - it's your chance to get in early on what could be the next big success story.
But here's the reality check: In the three years after going public, for the 8,775 IPOs from 1980 to 2020, the average IPO underperforms the market by -17.1% on an EW basis — Jay R. Ritter, IPOs and SPACs: Recent Developments. That's right - despite all the initial excitement, most IPOs actually disappoint investors in the medium term. Why? Because the hype often outweighs the actual business fundamentals.
The Hype Trap: Recognizing the Warning Signs
So how do you spot a potential hype trap? Look for these red flags:
1. Style Over Substance
Be wary of companies that spend more on marketing their IPO than explaining their path to profitability. As legendary investor Warren Buffett advises: "It's far better to buy a wonderful company at a fair price than a fair company at a wonderful price." (Berkshire Hathaway Annual Meeting). If the story sounds too good to be true, it probably is.
2. The Profitability Paradox
Many modern IPOs hit the market with staggering revenue growth but no profits. While this isn't automatically a deal-breaker, you need to ask: where are the unit economics headed? Is there a clear, credible path to profitability?
Finding the Real Gems: Your Due Diligence Checklist
Now for the good part - how to identify the potential winners:
1. Sustainable Competitive Advantage
Look for what Warren Buffett calls a "moat" - something that gives the company a lasting advantage over competitors. This could be proprietary technology, network effects, brand loyalty, or regulatory advantages. Ask yourself: can this company still be thriving five years from now?
2. Transparent Financials
Dig into the S-1 filing - the document companies must file with the SEC before going public. Pay special attention to the management discussion and risk factors. Look for consistent revenue growth, improving margins, and sensible cash burn rates.
3. Aligned Leadership
Study the management team. Do they have skin in the game? Are they retaining significant ownership?
The Smart Investor's Mindset
Remember Lykkers, the best investment opportunities aren't always the ones making the most noise. Sometimes, the most promising companies are those quietly building real value while the market chases the latest shiny object.
Don't feel pressured to buy on day one. Many successful companies see their IPO price dip in the first year, presenting better entry points for patient investors.
The next time IPO mania strikes, take a deep breath. Do your homework, focus on the fundamentals, and remember that in the stock market, patience and discipline usually beat excitement and impulse every time.
Stay curious and invest wisely!